02/11/09

Best Pizza in Philly Area

by MBEL63

Without a doubt,Gaetano's is the Best and is one of a kind,you probably have to go to Italy to find Pizza like this.

It may be expensive,but is definitely worth every cent.

It even taste great the next day heated up in the toaster oven (not microwave),that's when you know it's great pizza,when the cheese and sauce taste as fresh as it did the day before.

Be sure to order the Triple Cheese.

01/05/07

It's not Tacconelli's

by oldhead

It's not really that good, It's fair. Pinocchio's, Imperial, Cocoa's, Ciminera's, Thunderbird or Italian Delight are all local and much better. They act inside like the place is Tacconelli's with the dumb hours that they are open...it's not.

Geatanos also isn't the same Geatanos that are all over south jersey.

People in delco are so used to chain restaurants on Baltimore pike now. The only thing "special" is that they put the cheese on the bottom. I wish they could all travel back in time and go to Marra's. That was good pizza.

If you want to best slice around go to Celebre's Pizza on Packer Ave, next time your at a ball game. You can skip Geatano's who must have stuffed the ballot box to get the "best in delco" title. I dont know how they got the "title" when they have been closed most of last year...think about that.

If you want something better that's local, go to Ciminera's and get the provolone pizza. It's basically what Geatano's are ripping off anyway.

• Pros: plenty of parking in back
• Cons: expensive, bad hours, bad service, no credit cards, fair pizza

11/26/06

Not Good :(

by sallysamjordan

My husband brought home a half plain half pep pizza from this place and I really didn't like it. We never had cheese on the bottom and sauce on top pizza before. The sauce was very tasty but the cheese was rubbery and kind of made a noise on your teeth when you bite down.

• Pros: Great Sauce
• Cons: Rubbery Cheese